๐ŸŽน ๐ŸฆถDown. Up. That's not pedaling. {video}


Last week I told you the score is lying to you about pedal.

This week, I want to show you just how big that lie is.

The Henle edition of Beethoven has no pedal markings at all. Schnabel adds some, but barely. That's not an oversight, it's information.

Beethoven's rests carry the intensity. Pedaling through them blurs what he wrote.
โ€‹
Chopin treated pedal like a second voice.
โ€‹
Brahms used it to thicken the texture in ways the notation barely captured.
โ€‹
Three composers. Three completely different problems to solve. And your score gives you the same two instructions for all of them.

Down. Up.

That's not pedaling. That's compliance.

What actually exists is a spectrum.... half, quarter, slow, fast, flutter pedal.
โ€‹
Each one changes what the listener hears, what the room sounds like, what your piano actually does.

My new video, The Piano Pedal Mistake Even Advanced Pianists Make, shows you what that looks and sounds like in practice โ€” across three composers who couldn't be more different.

โ€‹Watch it here. โฌ‡๏ธ

video previewโ€‹

But you can't make pedal choices by watching someone else do it. In my workshop next week, you'll be at your piano the whole time, learning how to make pedal decisions with your ear.

๐Ÿ‘‰ SAVE YOUR SEAT FOR $10 โ€‹
before
it increases to $37 on May 14.

๐Ÿ“… Thursday, May 14 | Noon PT | 3 ET | 9 CET

By the end of 60 minutes, you won't just understand pedaling differently, you'll immediately start hearing deeper and pedaling with your ear. ๐Ÿ’ก

Registration includes 50 Shades of Pedaling Reference Guide, a composer-specific resource you'll keep at your piano.

๐Ÿ‘‰ RESERVE YOUR SEAT HEREโ€‹
โ€‹
โ€‹
โ€‹Play On,
Lisa Spector
Piano Practice Strategist
Founder,
Piano Ninja Tricksters Clubโ€‹

Lisa Spector, Piano Ninja

Juilliard graduate helping dedicated adult pianists who love challenging repertoire practice less while learning more.

Read more from Lisa Spector, Piano Ninja

I thought my competition days had ended more than 30 years ago. Apparently not. ๐Ÿคทโ™€๏ธ There are very few international piano competitions with no age limit. I only know of three.I've been recording for one of them this past week. I love the preparation. What I didn't love was what happened last week. The maximum submission length was 15 minutes, which isn't much time to make an impression. My plan was to submit Brahms's left-hand arrangement of the Bach Chaconne. It's an extraordinary piece,...

I started this weekly newsletter 6 months ago and have been searching for the right name for it, followed by a logo. And here it is, sitting at the top of your email. PRACTICE NOTESunfiltered. It didnโ€™t go perfectly. I knew when I landed on the name (after 48 iterations) but I originally started with a completely different design direction. It just wasnโ€™t landing. So I scrapped it and went somewhere entirely different before arriving at the logo you see now. And as soon as I had it, I knew....

Your score tells you when to pedal down and when to release. You know what it doesn't tell you? How slow or fast to pedal. ๐Ÿข ๐Ÿƒโ™€๏ธ That gap is where most of your pedaling decisions are happening on autopilot and you don't even know it. In this YouTube short from the recent 50 Shades of the Damper Pedal workshop, I'm playing 24 seconds of Debussy Reflets dans l'eau. I'm describing what to watch and listen for. Watch my foot. You'll notice it doesn't always move at the same speed. Sometimes fast....